All Echo Stories

Echo Stories · Fiction · Communication

I Said ‘I’m Fine’ and Hoped He’d Ask Again

Nina and Josh had set aside an evening together. When the plan changes, Nina says she’s fine and spends the rest of the night wishing he’d ask again.

Nina had already changed into the joggers with paint on the knee. There was a pizza in the oven and the remote was on Josh’s side of the sofa. They’d agreed to keep Friday free, the first evening they’d both had off in two weeks.

At seven, Josh rang. His mate had spare tickets to the football. He’d said yes, but he could still get back by ten. Was she all right with that?

Nina

Yeah. I’m fine. Go.

He thanked her and asked if she wanted chips on his way back. She said no. After hanging up she checked whether he’d call again, then felt ridiculous for checking.

When he got in, Josh put a bag of chips on the kitchen counter anyway. Nina gave him a small smile. He started telling her about a missed penalty. She could have told him what had bothered her then. Instead, she asked who took it.

At bedtime, he noticed she’d left his half of the pizza in the oven. ‘You could’ve eaten it,’ he said. Nina was about to say she hadn’t wanted it. What she wanted, suddenly, was one evening where she didn’t have to guess whether their plans counted.

What would you do?

Pick an option if you like, then open the ending to see what Nina did.

Reveal what Nina did

Nina took the pizza tray out and set it on the hob.

Nina

I said I was fine because you sounded excited. I was upset you’d already said yes before you called me. I’d been looking forward to tonight.

Josh started to say that he’d asked. He stopped halfway through and picked a burnt bit of cheese off the tray.

Josh

I did ask. But I’d already decided. I can see how that felt.

Nina told him she’d been waiting all evening for him to ask again. He said he’d believed her the first time. There was a pause, then they both laughed a little at how much work two words had done.

They agreed that next time an invitation came up, they’d check with each other before changing a plan. In the morning, Josh asked if they could keep Saturday evening free. Nina told him yes, and this time she meant it.